Rowan Scarborough at Fox News:
Navy SEALs have secretly captured one of the most wanted terrorists in Iraq — the alleged mastermind of the murder and mutilation of four Blackwater USA security guards in Fallujah in 2004. And three of the SEALs who captured him are now facing criminal charges, sources told FoxNews.com.
The three, all members of the Navy’s elite commando unit, have refused non-judicial punishment — called an admiral’s mast — and have requested a trial by court-martial.
Ahmed Hashim Abed, whom the military code-named “Objective Amber,” told investigators he was punched by his captors — and he had the bloody lip to prove it.
Now, instead of being lauded for bringing to justice a high-value target, three of the SEAL commandos, all enlisted, face assault charges and have retained lawyers.
Matthew McCabe, a Special Operations Petty Officer Second Class (SO-2), is facing three charges: dereliction of performance of duty for willfully failing to safeguard a detainee, making a false official statement, and assault.
Petty Officer Jonathan Keefe, SO-2, is facing charges of dereliction of performance of duty and making a false official statement.
Petty Officer Julio Huertas, SO-1, faces those same charges and an additional charge of impediment of an investigation.
Michael Goldfarb at The Weekly Standard:
Maybe there’s a whole lot more to this story than is currently being reported, but it’d have to be pretty terrible stuff to convince me that three Navy SEALs who successfully captured a high-value target now deserve to be court martialed for their service. A fat lip? That’s enough to get you rough military justice from the Obama administration, but blow up the World Trade Center and you get all the due process rights of the civilian criminal justice system. Sounds fair, right?
Looks awful, but I’m suspicious that it’s as bad as it seems given Fox’s misleading headline: “Navy SEALs Face Assault Charges for Capturing Most-Wanted Terrorist.” That makes it sound like the act of capturing him is the offense here, which would be insane even by the Army’s Nidal-Hasan standards of political correctness.
But that’s not what happened. They’re being charged for allegedly giving him a beating and covering it up.
[…]
I like Goldfarb’s take: “A fat lip? That’s enough to get you rough military justice from the Obama administration, but blow up the World Trade Center and you get all the due process rights of the civilian criminal justice system.” Even so, the fact that this turd got the Iraqi authorities involved may have left Central Command with little choice here. The last thing the military needs right now is another detainee-abuse headache, especially with some Iraqi pols already leaning on them about withdrawal. Giving the SEALs a zero-tolerance wrist slap reminds other troops not to do anything more seriously stupid that might be exploited politically. And it will be a wrist slap, I’m sure: The last thing The One needs after shipping KSM off to NYC for his close-up is the image of SEALs being hauled off to prison for busting some jihadi in the face. In fact, according to Fox, the SEALs requested a court-martial rather than nonjudicial punishment, presumably because they know full well how awful this looks for the military. Prediction: Wrist slap.
Blackfive on Allah Pundit’s post:
Let me explain something to you amigo. That wrist slap would be a career-ender in Spec Ops for these men. You understand? We take three guys who accomplish more in a lazy afternoon than you have in your entire anonymous, snarking-from-the-sideline, existence and we put them out of work making dead tangos. And that sounds like what should have happened to this ass clown. If he dies during the take down we have no problems.
I know you have no earthly clue just how god-awful complicated it is to actually perform a raid and scarf up a bad guy, let’s just say it rates up there with trying to conduct a Beethoven Symphony with your orchestra in free fall, screaming towards Earth like a phalanx of freaking lawn darts. That is why we like to send a f**king Hellfire down on them and last time I checked that leaves a little more than a god damn bloody lip. And yes I am saying I don’t care if he got it once he got to base. What if the guy who clocked his murderous ass knew Scott Helverson, who this bastard helped kill, burn and then defile his corpse? Do you really want to be on record saying he should be made an example of? Do you remember what Kos said about the four men this scumbag killed you dumbass? I’ll remind you “F**k them”. You are sure in illustrious company.
John Hinderaker at Powerline:
Our armed forces have become exquisitely sensitive–toward Nidal Malik Hasan and Ahmed Hashim Abed, and one wonders who else. Such sensitivity comes at a price, of course. But for now, at least, that price won’t be paid by those who set the policy.
UPDATE: Sean Linnane at FrumForum
But Robert Gates Will Quote Donald Trump
Genera David McKiernan replaced by Lt. General Stan McChrystal.
Two posts from Joe Klein at Swampland, here and here:
Andrew Exum in Foreign Policy:
Max Boot in Commentary:
Spencer Ackerman has a quote from an anonymous senior military official on McChrystal.
Tom Donnelly in the Weekly Standard.
James Joyner.
More when I find it.
UPDATE #1: Marc Ambinder, with the Sy Hersh angle.
Chris Good
Fred Kaplan in Slate
UPDATE #2: Sean Linnane in New Majority.
UPDATE #3: Kelley Vlahos in TAC.
Andrew Sullivan
UPDATE #4: A Sully round-up. Some of the posts:
George Packer in The New Yorker
Michael Yon
Judah Grunstein
Michael Cohen
Kori Schake in Foreign Policy
Other posts:
David Zirin in The Nation, with more on the Pat Tillman connection.
Benjamin H. Friedman at Cato
UPDATE #5: More Sullivan
UPDATE #6: Andrew Sullivan again.
Spencer Ackerman, here, here, here, here, here and here. And here.
UPDATE #7: Rajiv Chandrasekaran in WaPo
More Ackerman
UPDATE #8: Kevin Drum
2 Comments
Filed under Af/Pak, Foreign Affairs
Tagged as Andrew Exum, Andrew Sullivan, Benjamin H. Friedman, Cato, Chris Good, Commentary, David Zirin, Foreign Policy, Fred Kaplan, George Packer, James Joyner, Joe Klein, Judah Grunstein, Kelley Vlahos, Kevin Drum, Kori Schake, Marc Ambinder, Max Boot, Michael Cohen, Michael Yon, New Majority, New Yorker, Rajiv Chandrasekaran, Sean Linnane, Slate, Spencer Ackerman, Swampland, The American Conservative, The Nation, The Weekly Standard, Time, Tom Donnelly, Washington Post